Lossy vs. Lossless
Throughout this post, I use the terms lossy and lossless, where the former means the sound is not the exact original (has loss), and the latter means the sound is the exact original (has no loss). By way of example, a lossy sound format is MP3 and a lossless format is WAV (otherwise referred to as PCM or Pulse Code Modulation as this is the most common use for WAV).
HD-DVD sound parity with DVD
Both DVD and HD-DVD support the lossy Dolby Digital (DD) and DTS surround formats which have a max bitstream of 1.5Mbps. There are four interconnects with enough bandwidth to output this lossy surround signal from your source player to an audio/video receiver (AVR):
- Discrete analog outputs
- Digital Optical (S/PDIF)
- Digital Coax
- HDMI (which will also carry video)
If the discrete analog outputs are used, the digital-to-analog (D/A) conversion happens in the source player rather than the AVR. For all digital outputs (including HDMI), the maximum 1.5Mbps bitstream is simply sent over the digital interconnect to the AVR for D/A conversion.
The only time sound quality would be better using the discrete analog outputs of your source player would be if the analog pre-amp and D/A converters in the source player were better then in the AVR. This is generally not true except for the higher end players (or you have a poor quality receiver).
High Definition Multimedia Interface (HDMI)
HDMI is a single cable high-bandwidth solution for transporting both audio and video. There are three versions: 1.1, 1.2, and 1.3, with 1.1 or 1.2 being in almost every piece of recent consumer electronics equipment today. 1.3 is brand new and adds some new value, but to be explicitly clear:
YOU DO NOT NEED HDMI v1.3 TO EXPERIENCE THE NEW HD AUDIO FORMATS. Both versions 1.1 and 1.2 support the bandwidth necessary for 7.1 channels of 24bit/96kHz audio (discrete analog outputs is also an option if HDMI is not). For the eager minds, 24bit/96kHz is better than big budget Hollywood films which master at 24bit/48kHz, and ordinary films which typically master at 16bit/48kHz.
Speculation as to why pre-HDMI digital interconnects weren’t revisioned
I’m fairly certain digital optical (S/PDIF) and digital coax were not revisioned to support the higher bandwidth needed for the new lossless formats because a single cable for carrying audio and video is a preferred setup experience. HDMI had this promise already, and also supported a copy protection scheme supported by content owners. While it may have been possible to revision existing digital interconnect to meet bandwidth and copy protection needs, receivers would also have to be updated (hopefully just a firmware update), and consumers would still be forced to connect two separate wires and deal with potential synchronization issues between audio and video. In the end, the value of HDMI far exceeded the cost of not sticking with existing interconnect. If a reader has more background on this, I’d love to hear it.
HD-DVD sound advancements beyond DVD
Unlike DVD, HD-DVD also supports two new compressed lossless surround sound formats: Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD Master Audio. As a side note, typically the compression schemes used that can still achieve lossless reproduction are a 2:1 ratio (compressed to half the original size). Additionally, uncompressed lossless multi-channel PCM is supported. As fate would have it, there are also two new lossy formats with improvements over Dolby Digital and DTS: Dolby Digital Plus (DD+) and DTS-HD High Resolution Audio.
All HD-DVD players are required to support every Dolby format; with the two new DTS HD formats as optional.
Additionally, all HD-DVD players are required to decode all audio formats (including the legacy ones) in the source player into multi-channel uncompressed PCM (so it can be mixed with picture-in-picture and menu sound effects), which is far to big to fit over digital optical or digital coax (in reality, the physical cable has the bandwidth, but the standards which govern how the bits are sent over the interconnect do not support the necessary throughput). The uncompressed lossless multi-channel PCM format can; however, be sent over HDMI (any version) or have the D/A conversion happen in the source player and output over the discrete analog outputs.
So, if any of the new lossy or lossless audio formats are used by the HD-DVD source content (what’s on the disk), and a digital optical or coax interconnect is used, the resultant multi-channel uncompressed PCM is automatically re-encoded on-the-fly by the source player (to Dolby Digital or DTS) to fit over that interconnect. In effect, the value of lossless sound is lost and DVD sound parity is the result. Importantly though, you’ll still get great sound, even if it isn’t as great as it could be.
The only way to achieve full fidelity lossless reproduction of the new lossless HD sound formats (or any of the new lossy HD formats) is to use the discrete analog outputs, or HDMI (remember, you don’t need v1.3).
What’s the confusion around HDMI 1.3?
Simple: the HDMI website clearly says that v1.3 is required for the new HD lossless formats. This is true only in the sense that v1.3 allows for the raw Dolby Digital TrueHD and DTS-HD Master Audio bitstreams, as opposed to the uncompressed multi-channel PCM bitstreams, to be sent over the interconnect. This is extremely misleading. Note that sending the raw bitstream would also require the AVR to support the corresponding decoders, but would have the additional value of enabling product differentiation by higher-end digital components and processing of the streams. At the end of the day; however, whether the bitstream is the raw compressed lossless format, or the uncompressed multi-channel PCM format, the audio transfer is lossless (bit for bit the same audio). Importantly, you don’t have to upgrade your AVR or use HDMI v1.3 interconnect to get HD sound. You could in the future upgrade your AVR and have HDMI v1.3 interconnect for potential improvements by way of processing enhancements, but there is no reason to wait.
Conclusion
- If your AVR has HDMI inputs (and processes the sound rather than simply providing interconnect switching) and your HD-DVD player has HDMI output, you can get benefit of all new formats.
- If your AVR has discrete analog inputs (most do) and your HD-DVD player has discrete analog outputs, you can get benefit of all new HD audio formats.
- If you don’t have, or can’t use, HDMI or discrete analog interconnect, you’ll get DVD parity sound (the HD-DVD player will trans-code on-the-fly automatically).
- Your AVR does not have to understand any of the new required HD audio codecs (remember, the receiver sees a linear PCM bitstream).
Let me know if you have any questions or want me to expand more on the topic.
P.S. Thanks to all the bright folks at Microsoft who helped me understand all this voodoo.
Next in series